Extra Soft Bread Machine Bread - Recipe & Video - Bread Dad (2024)

This recipe produces an extra soft bread machine bread. It is a delicious white bread that is perfect for sandwiches. The softness of this bread is due to the use of Greek yogurt or sour cream as an ingredient.

Greek yogurt & sour cream tenderizes the gluten in bread and this results in a very soft & fluffy bread machine bread. Your family will love the taste & softness of this white bread… and you will love how easy it is to make with your bread machine.

Extra Soft Bread Machine White Bread

Recipe Sections

• Ingredients
• Instructions
• Recipe Video
• Helpful Tips

Other recipes claim that they create the softest or fluffiest white breads with a bread machine. However, if they are just using bread flour, butter/oil, milk/water, sugar, yeast and salt to make their bread then they are seriously over exaggerating mistaken. They are just making regular bread. Their recipe is probably similar to the basic white bread recipes that you find in most bread machine instruction manuals. Decent bread but not extra soft.

To get very soft bread, you need to add an extra ingredient that tenderizes the gluten in the bread flour. A number of ingredients can do this and they include yogurt, buttermilk, sour cream, etc. The slight acidity of these ingredients helps to break down the gluten and this creates a softer bread. I use Greek yogurt in this soft white bread machine recipe because it is easy to get and comes in a wide variety of flavors (i.e. blueberry Greek yogurt).

Sliced Soft White Bread Machine Bread

Ingredients

• 3/4 Cup – Greek Yogurt – 178 milliliters – You can also use sour cream
• 3/4 Cup – Milk (warm) – 178 milliliters
• 4 Tablespoons – Unsalted Butter (sliced & softened) – 57 grams
• 3 1/2 Cups – Bread Flour – 420 grams
• 3 Tablespoons – White Granulated Sugar – 37 grams
• 1 1/4 Teaspoons – Salt – 7.5 grams
• 1 1/4 Teaspoons – Bread Machine Yeast (Instant Yeast) – 4 grams – Not active dry yeast

Servings – Roughly 12 Slices

Equipment Needed – Measuring cup & spoons, silicone spatula, oven mitts, cooling rack and a bread machine.

Recipe Video – Watch How This Bread Is Made

Instructions

• Machine Settings to Use – Light Color, 2 lb and Basic Bread Setting
• Soften the butter in your microwave. FYI – I like to semi-melt the butter.
• Premix the Greek yogurt (or sour cream). FYI – This helps you to better measure the Greek yogurt (or sour cream) in a measuring cup and helps evenly distribute any fruit if you use a fruit-flavored Greek yogurt.
• Unplug your bread machine.
• Remove the bread pan from the unplugged bread machine (so when you add the ingredients, they can not accidentally spill into the machine).
• Add the Greek yogurt (or sour cream), milk and butter into the bread pan and then add the remaining ingredients. Place the bread machine yeast in last and the yeast should not touch the liquid (until the bread machine is turned on and the ingredients start to be mixed together by the bread machine).
• Put bread pan with ingredients back into unplugged bread machine.
• Plug in bread machine. Enter the correct settings (Light Color, 2 lb and Basic Bread Setting) and press the “Start” button.
• When the bread machine has finished baking the bread, unplug the bread machine and remove the bread pan from the bread machine. Wear oven mitts as the bread pan & bread machine will be hot.
• Remove the bread from the bread pan and place the bread on a cooling rack. Use oven mitts when removing the bread as the bread & bread pan will be hot.
• Optional – Right after you remove the hot bread from the bread pan and place it on the cooling rack, you can use a pastry brush to brush a very light coat of melted butter on the top of the bread. This creates a more golden crust and adds even more buttery flavor. This works best when the bread is still hot. FYI – Do not use too much melted butter or it will run all over the sides of the bread. Also do not brush on after the bread has cooled down.
• Let the bread cool on the cooling rack for 1-2 hours before cutting.
• Please read the tips section below for extra information on how to make this recipe successfully & to avoid common bread machine problems. You also can watch my recipe video below to “see” how to perform each recipe step.

If you liked this recipe, please leave a comment & 5 star rating. It is always fantastic to hear from someone who has enjoyed my recipes! Jump to comment section

Other Bread Dad Sections

• Bread Machine Cookbooks
• Bread Machines – My favorites!
• Bread Mixes – Buttermilk, rye, sourdough, French, etc.
• Bread Tools – Bread slicers, etc.

Secret Ingredient for an Extra Soft White Bread = Greek Yogurt

See Also

How to Make Hand Milled Soap (Plus A Charcoal & Anise Soap Recipe)Honey/Oat Sandwich Bread Machine Recipe | ~Texas Homesteader~Homemade Laundry Detergent Recipe - Around $30 for a Year's Worth!We're building an aquaponics garden! • Steamy Kitchen Recipes Giveaways

Helpful Tips

• The tips below are designed to help bread machine “novices” and those who haven’t touched their bread machine in years.
• Click on our “print recipe” link if you want to print out this recipe. It includes all of the recipe’s ingredients and instructions. However, the recipe print function does not include our tips section. Please read the tips section in order to avoid common recipe problems.
• If you would rather “see” how this recipe is made, please watch the step-by-step recipe video on this page. It is a short & simple video that shows you how to make this recipe.
• This recipe is part of Bread Dad’s series on easy Bread Machine Recipes such as whole wheat bread, rye bread, French bread and cinnamon raisin bread.

• This soft white bread machine recipe works only in bread machines with at least a 2 lb loaf capacity. These machines are large enough to handle the rise of this fluffy bread machine bread.
• Since this soft white bread machine recipe uses 3 1/2 cups of bread flour, it is in reality roughly a 1.75 lb loaf. However, you want to use the 2 lb setting in order to get a few more minutes of dough rising time (versus the 1.5 lb setting) and because the bread is so soft & fluffy (it needs a little extra room in the bread machine).
• This recipe will NOT work in smaller 1 lb or 1.5 lb capacity bread machines. Please check the capacity of your bread machine before making this recipe. If you have a small bread machine (i.e. a bread machine that has only a capacity for 1 lb breads), you will be unable to make this recipe. The loaf will be too large for your machine and overflow the bread pan (and the top is likely to collapse). An example of a bread machine with only a 1 lb capacity is the Zojirushi Home Bakery Mini Breadmaker (model BB-HAC10).

• You need to use Greek yogurt (not regular yogurt) to make this bread. Regular yogurt is a little more liquidy than Greek yogurt. This extra moisture may throw off the recipe if regular yogurt is used as a substitute for Greek yogurt. Also (in my opinion) regular yogurt doesn’t seem to tenderize the bread as well.
• This is a bread machine version of our oven-baked Greek Yogurt Bread. You should try out our oven-baked version if you want to make a “normal” shaped bread loaf (versus a block-shaped bread machine loaf). You can also tweak the oven version a little more easily (i.e. add different toppings).
• The bread machine version on this page is slightly different (i.e. less yeast) than the oven baked version. The oven baked version rises too high if baked in a regular-sized bread machine (versus an oven).
• The fluffy bread machine recipe on this page produces an extra soft white bread. However, if you are looking for a more traditional white bread (made without Greek yogurt), you should try our regular Bread Machine White Bread Recipe. It creates an extra buttery white bread made with milk, bread flour, butter, etc.
• Or try making my Buttermilk Bread or Honey White Bread recipes. These bread machine recipes produce delicious white breads too.

• FYI – The 3/4 cup of Greek yogurt mentioned in the ingredient list is based on a MEASURING CUP (and not on 3/4 of a small Greek yogurt container). If you do not use the correct measurement then your bread will not come out properly.
• I would recommend using an all natural Greek yogurt and not artificially sweetened yogurt when making this soft bread machine bread. In my opinion, the bread can occasionally have a slight chemical taste when using some artificially sweetened yogurts. Nevertheless, this recipe works fine with artificially sweetened Greek yogurt if that is all that you have.
• You should use plain Greek yogurt if you want a “traditional” (non flavored) extra soft bread machine white bread. However, if you want a soft bread machine bread with a hint of fruit flavor & aroma, I would suggest trying a fruit flavored Greek yogurt. My favorite to use is blueberry Greek yogurt. Try to use a Greek yogurt with lots of fruit flavor for the best results. FYI – When I tried making this recipe with strawberry flavored Greek yogurt, I did not taste or smell any strawberries. Blueberry flavored Greek yogurt was the more “effective” (in my tests of strawberry vs blueberry yogurt) in achieving a hint of fruit flavor & aroma. Of course, this may vary based on the yogurt brand.
• Extra benefit – Most Greek yogurts will add some protein to your bread.

• You can also make this recipe with sour cream (instead of Greek yogurt). The sour cream version of this soft bread comes out just as tender as the Greek yogurt version. However, the sour cream version will be a “plain” soft white bread versus the possible fruit-flavored white bread that you can make with Greek yogurt.
• If you want to make an OVEN-baked version of this bread with sour cream, please try my Sour Cream Bread Recipe (an extra soft white bread recipe). It uses sour cream to tenderize the gluten.
• Visitors – Do you like to use plain Greek yogurt, fruit flavored Greek yogurt or sour cream to make this bread? Do you like to add anything else when making this bread? Chopped nuts? Dried cranberries? Raisins? Something else? Please leave your ingredient thoughts & suggestions in the comment box below.

• Warning – Given the bread’s extra softness & the moisture variability of different Greek yogurts, this bread tends to crack a little more on the sides of the bread “crown”. See the picture below to get an idea of the type of crack (left side of picture).
• I have tried solving this issue with less yeast (bread was too small), less yogurt (not fluffy & less tasty), less milk (dough was too hard), less flour (bread ended up too small & not fluffy enough), different machine settings (i.e. sweet bread setting), etc.
• After dozens of experiments (and countless Greek yogurts sacrificed for science!), the soft white bread machine recipe on this page was the best solution for my bread machine. It creates an extra soft white bread but with a little more cracking potential. Therefore, don’t be surprised if you don’t have a perfectly rounded bread top. This is a small price to pay for an extra soft & fluffy bread machine bread.
• If you want to minimize cracks, you should make my oven-baked Greek Yogurt Bread Recipe or Sour Cream Bread Recipe. You have more control with an oven-based recipe (i.e. due to more flexibility with the time used for dough rises, baking length and temperatures) versus the standard settings on a bread machine (which have preset rises, baking lengths & temperatures).

Bread with “Crack” (Left Side)

• This recipe uses bread machine yeast (instant yeast). It does NOT use active dry yeast.
• If you haven’t used your bread machine or bread maker in a long time, please buy some NEW bread machine yeast before making your bread. Old yeast can die or lose its potency and this will lead to bread that does not rise properly. Bread machine yeast is not likely to be viable if it has been sitting in your pantry for years.
• Many bakers like to make an indent in the top of the flour in order to hold the bread machine yeast in place (looks sort of like a small flour volcano with a yeast crater). This is done to prevent the yeast from falling into the liquid ingredients (and activating prematurely), coming into contact with the salt, etc. until the bread machine is turned on.
• I would recommend NOT reducing the salt in this recipe. You generally want to keep the salt-to-yeast ratio at a 1:1 basis in most bread recipes. The salt moderates the growth of the yeast. If you cut the salt (and disrupt this 1:1 ratio), the yeast will grow faster than expected. In turn, this leads to more bread collapses (because the yeast rises too high and then craters in the middle) and/or results in “slack” less manageable dough. In addition, less salt will impact the flavor and browning of the bread.

• Do not use cold milk. The main problem with using regular milk is that people tend to use cold refrigerated milk and this can slow the yeast growth. Try to use warm milk (or instant powdered milk mixed into warm water). Yeast likes liquids are that not too cold or too hot. If the milk is too cold, you might end up with a denser bread (because the yeast has not risen properly).
• Optional – If you have run out of milk, you can use water as a substitute. However, while still good, bread made with water will be a little less tasty.
• Optional – As I stated in the instructions – Right after you have removed the hot bread from the bread pan, you can “baste” the top of the bread with melted butter. A small pastry brush works best to brush on the melted butter. This optional step helps to improve the appearance of the bread and adds some extra buttery flavor.
• If you like very soft white bread machine breads, you should also try out Bread Machine Buttermilk Bread. Buttermilk works similarly to Greek yogurt and tenderizes the gluten in the bread. However, you can not simply replace the Greek yogurt in this recipe with buttermilk because the buttermilk is more “liquidy” (than Greek yogurt). You need to use the dedicated buttermilk recipe.

• Use FRESH ingredients (i.e. flour) for the best results. Ingredients that have been sitting in the pantry for months can become stale or pick up weird smells & flavors. Try to keep your ingredients (i.e. flour) in airtight food containers in order to extend their shelf life.
• If your bread comes out too dense, it is likely due to one of the following reasons; You are using old or stale yeast, using a cold refrigerator temperature liquid (which slows yeast growth), baking in a cold winter temperature kitchen (yeast likes kitchen temps of 75-80 degree F), using all purpose flour (versus bread flour as called for in the recipe), placing salt on top of or next to the yeast (salt kills yeast so it must be placed away from the yeast in the bread pan), etc. For more reasons, you should visit Bread Dad’s Why Is My Bread Machine Bread So Dense? page.
• Kitchen humidity can impact a recipe. A winter kitchen tends to be drier due to your heating system drying out the air. In contrast, a kitchen in the summer can be much more humid. This change in humidity impacts baking as flour can soak up humidity from the air. Therefore, you might have to add 1-2 teaspoons of liquid in the winter if the dough is looking too dry. Or you might have to add 1-2 teaspoons of flour in the summer if the dough is looking too wet. If your kitchen is very dry or humid, you might have to add even a little more (but start with 1 teaspoon at a time until you achieve the right consistency). Of course, excessive kitchen humidity or dryness can impact a recipe at any time during the year (not just in the summer & winter)!
• This is one of the reasons that people should store flour in an airtight container if they have already opened the flour package. The flour will pick up extra moisture from the air while sitting in the pantry and this can throw off recipes, spoil flavor, degrade shelf life, etc.
• If your bread is not completely cooled (esp. soft breads), you are more likely to squash & tear the bread when slicing the bread. Many of my sandwich breads take at least 1-2 hours to cool down (after being placed on a wire cooling rack). FYI – After an hour of cooling, I like to check my bread to see if it needs further cooling. Do not be tempted by the smell of delicious hot bread & cut too early… if you want nice slices! Let the bread completely cool.

• If you have a problem with a “basic” bread machine recipe, please make sure that you are following the recipe exactly (i.e. using the correct bread machine settings), using the correct amount of an ingredient (i.e. don’t eyeball the measurements versus using a measuring cup or accidentally add a tablespoon when a teaspoon is called for), using the correct ingredients (i.e. bread machine yeast versus regular yeast or bread flour versus all purpose flour), etc. Please don’t “wing” things with recipes.
• If you start substituting ingredients (i.e. using different types of flour not called for in the recipe), you are experimenting and should not expect similar results to the recipe shown above. Experimenting can be fun. However, you should expect some successes but more potential disappointments when you start to experiment with recipes. For example, if you substitute whole wheat flour for bread flour, you will probably experience a problem (as whole wheat flour doesn’t rise nearly as well as bread flour). Moreover, whole wheat flour has a totally different flavor.
• Bread machine yeast loses its potency over time. Generally, bread machine yeast lasts for only 3-4 months after you have opened the bottle. However, if the yeast is exposed to air & moisture (i.e. the bottle is not sealed tight) or exposed to higher temperatures, the yeast will expire even more quickly.
• Once you have opened the bottle that contains the bread machine yeast, the yeast will last longer if you store the bottle in the refrigerator or freezer. Just make sure the bottle is sealed tight (as yeast will deteriorate quickly if exposed to air, moisture and/or heat).

• My recipes are based on US ingredient measurements (i.e. US cups & tablespoons). However, as a courtesy to our European visitors, I have also included some very ROUGH European equivalents (i.e. grams & milliliters). Since I rarely use European measurements when baking, please let me know in the comment section below if any of the European ingredient measurements need to be changed (i.e. for XYZ ingredient, milliliters are more commonly used versus the grams information listed in the recipe).
• Before using any bread machine, you should read the bread machine manufacturer’s instructions in order to use the bread machine effectively and safely.
• Always wear oven mitts/gloves when dealing with a bread machine. The bread pan and the rest of the bread machine can get very hot during the baking process. This means that the bread pan and bread machine is likely to be very hot when you attempt to remove a baked good from the bread machine and/or bread pan.
• For more easy bread ideas, please visit Bread Dad’s sections on Bread Machine Recipes and Homemade Bread Recipes.

If you liked this recipe, please leave a comment & 5 star rating. It is always fantastic to hear from someone who has enjoyed my recipes! Jump to comment section

Highlighted Recipe

• High Fiber Bread Recipe – When you get a little older, some people (like me) need extra fiber in their diet. So check out this delicious & fiber-icious bread recipe.

Other Bread Dad Sections

• Bread Machines – My favorites!
• Bread Machine Cookbooks
• Bread Mixes – Ingredient kits for buttermilk bread, rye bread, sourdough bread, French bread, Italian country bread, etc.
• – Ingredient kits for homemade blondies, snickerdoodles, chocolate donuts, pecan brownies, etc.
• – Turn your homemade bread into delicious sandwiches or toasty paninis.

Questions & Answers

Why is my bread machine bread so hard?

For the softest breads, you should look for bread machine bread recipes that use yogurt, buttermilk or sour cream. These ingredients “tenderize” the gluten and this usually results in softer breads (versus breads that do not use these ingredients). However, this only works for recipes that utilize types of flour with lots of gluten (i.e. bread flour).

You also need to make sure that you are using fresh yeast because old/expired yeast will not rise properly and your bread will come out very dense. In addition, you need to use the correct bread machine setting as some settings will overbake the bread and the crust will come out drier and harder. An incorrect setting may also not provide enough time for the dough to rise properly (resulting in a short & dense bread). For softer crusts, you should also use the light color crust setting (versus the medium and dark color crust settings).

For more information, you should read our “Why is my bread machine bread so dense?” page.

If you liked this recipe, please leave a comment & 5 star rating. It is always fantastic to hear from someone who has enjoyed my recipes! Jump to comment section

Reference Sources

• Wikipedia, Bread Machine
• Wikipedia, Greek Yogurt

Related Recipes

• Bread Machine All Purpose Flour Bread
• Bread Machine White Bread – Extra buttery
• Buttermilk Bread – Oven baked
• Greek Yogurt Bread – Oven baked
• Soft White Bread – Oven baked (uses sour cream)
• White Bread Instant Yeast – Oven baked

Please leave a comment & recipe rating in the comment box below. Thanks!